Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Your cart

Loading...

Order special instructions

Order special instructions

Estimated total

$0.00 USD

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout

Facebook
Instagram
Twitter

Order all the products you love in our store.

Enjoy all the same in-store sales.

Pickup or delivery within 4 hours!

Shop
- Produce
  
  Fresh Fruits
  
  Fresh Vegetables
  
  Fresh Herbs
- Meat
  
  Fresh Chicken
  
  Fresh Pork
  
  Bacon and Breakfast Sausages
  
  Fresh Beef
  
  Fresh Seafood
  
  Fresh Lamb, Veal and Bison
  
  Fresh Turkey
  
  Plant-Based Meat
  
  Lunch Meats
  
  Hot Dogs and Sausages
  
  Specialty Meats
- Frozen
  
  Frozen Fruits
  
  Frozen Vegetables
  
  Ice Cream and Popsicles
  
  Ice Cream Cones
  
  Frozen Desserts
  
  Frozen Meat and Seafood
  
  Frozen Plant-Based Meat
  
  Frozen Breakfast
  
  Frozen Pizza
  
  Frozen Juice, Mixers and Broths
  
  Frozen Bread and Dough
  
  Frozen Snacks
  
  Frozen Meals and Sides
  
  Ice
- Dairy & Eggs
  
  Milk
  
  Cheese
  
  Yogurt & Yogurt Drinks
  
  Eggs and Egg Substitutes
  
  Butter and Margarine
  
  Plant-Based Milk
  
  Cottage Cheese
  
  Sour Cream, Cream Cheese and Dips
  
  Cream and Creamer
  
  Pudding and Gelatin
  
  Refrigerated Dough and Crust
- Personal Care
  
  Oral Care
  
  Skin Care
  
  Bath and Shower
  
  Deodorant
  
  Shaving and Grooming
  
  Eye and Ear Care
  
  Feminine Care
  
  Hand Soap and Sanitizers
  
  Tissues and Wipes
  
  Nail Care
- Health Care
  
  Cold, Flu and Allergy
  
  Pain and Fever
  
  First Aid
  
  Digestion and Stomach Relief
  
  Children's Health Care
  
  Muscle and Joint Care
  
  Home Healthcare Solutions
  
  Other Care
- Cleaning & Household Supplies
  
  Laundry Detergent
  
  Fabric Softeners
  
  Laundry Care
  
  Bleach
  
  Paper Towels
  
  Toilet Paper and Wipes
  
  Cleaning Supplies
  
  Dishwashing Needs
  
  Cleaning Tools
  
  Trash Bins and Bags
  
  Housewares
  
  Pest Control
  
  Office and Stationary
  
  Electronics and Mobile Accessories
  
  Tools and Home Improvement
- Vitamins & Supplements
  
  Letter Vitamins
  
  Herbal Supplements
  
  Protein and Energy Supplements
  
  Other Supplements
More Departments
- Bakery
  
  Cakes, Cupcakes and Pies
  
  Other Desserts
  
  Cookies and Brownies
  
  Bread
  
  Buns and Rolls
  
  Bagels and Muffins
  
  Breakfast Pastries
  
  Pitas, Tortillas and Wraps
  
  Pizza Shells and Flatbreads
- Beverages
  
  Water and Sparkling Water
  
  Soda and Pop
  
  Sports and Energy Drinks
  
  Coffee
  
  Tea and Iced Tea
  
  Juice
  
  Milk
  
  Kombucha and Probiotic Drinks
  
  Protein Drinks
  
  Drink Mixes and Enhancers
  
  Mixers and Non-Alcoholic Drinks
- Breakfast
  
  Cereal
  
  Granola
  
  Breakfast Bars
  
  Oatmeal
  
  Nut Butters
  
  Pancake, Waffle and Baking Mixes
  
  Maple Syrup, Honey and Sweeteners
  
  Jams and Jellies
  
  Toaster Pastries
  
  Bacon and Breakfast Sausages
  
  Breakfast Pastries
  
  Frozen Breakfast
- Canned Goods & Soups
  
  Canned Tomatoes
  
  Soup, Stew and Chili
  
  Canned Beans
  
  Canned Meat and Fish
  
  Canned Fruit
  
  Canned Vegetables
  
  Broths and Stocks
- Condiments & Sauces
  
  Pasta Sauce
  
  Hot Sauce
  
  Ketchup, Mustard and Relish
  
  Olives and Pickled Goods
  
  Salad Dressings and Toppings
  
  Syrup, Honey and Sweeteners
  
  Jams and Jellies
  
  Nut Butters
  
  Salsa
  
  International Sauce
  
  Oils and Vinegars
  
  Pastes
  
  More Condiments and Sauces
- Pasta & Dry Goods
  
  Pasta
  
  Rice and Grains
  
  Noodles and Ramen
  
  Boxed Sides and Meals
  
  Beans
  
  Seeds
  
  Spices and Seasonings
  
  Dry Soup
  
  More Dry Goods
- Baking Goods
  
  Baking Mixes
  
  Frosting and Cake Decorations
  
  Baking Milks
  
  Baking Chocolate
  
  Flour
  
  Maple Syrup, Honey and Sweeteners
  
  Baking Powders
  
  Pie Crusts and Fillings
  
  Extracts
  
  Sugars
  
  Marshmallows
  
  Ice Cream Cones
- Snacks & Candy
  
  Chocolate and Candy
  
  Chips
  
  Popcorn and Pretzels
  
  Snack Bars
  
  Cookies and Crackers
  
  Nuts, Seeds and Dried Fruits
  
  Pudding and Snack Cups
  
  Jerky
  
  Gum and Mints
  
  More Snacks
- Pet Care
  
  Dry Dog Food
  
  Wet Dog Food
  
  Dog Treats
  
  Dry Cat Food
  
  Wet Cat Food
  
  Cat Treats
  
  Dog Toys and Supplies
  
  Cat Toys and Supplies
  
  Bird Care
- Alcohol
  
  Beer
  
  Wine
  
  Spirits
  
  Mixers and Non-Alcoholic Drinks
  
  Cider
  
  Ready to Drink
- Baby & Child Care
  
  Diapers, Wipes and Creams
  
  Baby Food and Drinks
  
  Baby Health Care
- Kitchen & Dining
  
  Foil and Plastic Wrap
  
  Napkins
  
  Cookware and Bakeware
  
  Dining Utensils
  
  Kitchen Gadgets and Appliances
  
  Food Storage
  
  Disposable Utensils, Plates and Cups
Catering
Sandwich Order Form
Vintage Wine & Spirits
About Us
Contact
Shop & Give
Personal Shopping Form
Holiday Meals
Meat Dept Turkey Orders
Apply for a Job

Twitter
Facebook
Instagram

Shop
- Produce
  
  Fresh Fruits
  
  Fresh Vegetables
  
  Fresh Herbs
- Meat
  
  Fresh Chicken
  
  Fresh Pork
  
  Bacon and Breakfast Sausages
  
  Fresh Beef
  
  Fresh Seafood
  
  Fresh Lamb, Veal and Bison
  
  Fresh Turkey
  
  Plant-Based Meat
  
  Lunch Meats
  
  Hot Dogs and Sausages
  
  Specialty Meats
- Frozen
  
  Frozen Fruits
  
  Frozen Vegetables
  
  Ice Cream and Popsicles
  
  Ice Cream Cones
  
  Frozen Desserts
  
  Frozen Meat and Seafood
  
  Frozen Plant-Based Meat
  
  Frozen Breakfast
  
  Frozen Pizza
  
  Frozen Juice, Mixers and Broths
  
  Frozen Bread and Dough
  
  Frozen Snacks
  
  Frozen Meals and Sides
  
  Ice
- Dairy & Eggs
  
  Milk
  
  Cheese
  
  Yogurt & Yogurt Drinks
  
  Eggs and Egg Substitutes
  
  Butter and Margarine
  
  Plant-Based Milk
  
  Cottage Cheese
  
  Sour Cream, Cream Cheese and Dips
  
  Cream and Creamer
  
  Pudding and Gelatin
  
  Refrigerated Dough and Crust
- Personal Care
  
  Oral Care
  
  Skin Care
  
  Bath and Shower
  
  Deodorant
  
  Shaving and Grooming
  
  Eye and Ear Care
  
  Feminine Care
  
  Hand Soap and Sanitizers
  
  Tissues and Wipes
  
  Nail Care
- Health Care
  
  Cold, Flu and Allergy
  
  Pain and Fever
  
  First Aid
  
  Digestion and Stomach Relief
  
  Children's Health Care
  
  Muscle and Joint Care
  
  Home Healthcare Solutions
  
  Other Care
- Cleaning & Household Supplies
  
  Laundry Detergent
  
  Fabric Softeners
  
  Laundry Care
  
  Bleach
  
  Paper Towels
  
  Toilet Paper and Wipes
  
  Cleaning Supplies
  
  Dishwashing Needs
  
  Cleaning Tools
  
  Trash Bins and Bags
  
  Housewares
  
  Pest Control
  
  Office and Stationary
  
  Electronics and Mobile Accessories
  
  Tools and Home Improvement
- Vitamins & Supplements
  
  Letter Vitamins
  
  Herbal Supplements
  
  Protein and Energy Supplements
  
  Other Supplements
More Departments
- Bakery
  
  Cakes, Cupcakes and Pies
  
  Other Desserts
  
  Cookies and Brownies
  
  Bread
  
  Buns and Rolls
  
  Bagels and Muffins
  
  Breakfast Pastries
  
  Pitas, Tortillas and Wraps
  
  Pizza Shells and Flatbreads
- Beverages
  
  Water and Sparkling Water
  
  Soda and Pop
  
  Sports and Energy Drinks
  
  Coffee
  
  Tea and Iced Tea
  
  Juice
  
  Milk
  
  Kombucha and Probiotic Drinks
  
  Protein Drinks
  
  Drink Mixes and Enhancers
  
  Mixers and Non-Alcoholic Drinks
- Breakfast
  
  Cereal
  
  Granola
  
  Breakfast Bars
  
  Oatmeal
  
  Nut Butters
  
  Pancake, Waffle and Baking Mixes
  
  Maple Syrup, Honey and Sweeteners
  
  Jams and Jellies
  
  Toaster Pastries
  
  Bacon and Breakfast Sausages
  
  Breakfast Pastries
  
  Frozen Breakfast
- Canned Goods & Soups
  
  Canned Tomatoes
  
  Soup, Stew and Chili
  
  Canned Beans
  
  Canned Meat and Fish
  
  Canned Fruit
  
  Canned Vegetables
  
  Broths and Stocks
- Condiments & Sauces
  
  Pasta Sauce
  
  Hot Sauce
  
  Ketchup, Mustard and Relish
  
  Olives and Pickled Goods
  
  Salad Dressings and Toppings
  
  Syrup, Honey and Sweeteners
  
  Jams and Jellies
  
  Nut Butters
  
  Salsa
  
  International Sauce
  
  Oils and Vinegars
  
  Pastes
  
  More Condiments and Sauces
- Pasta & Dry Goods
  
  Pasta
  
  Rice and Grains
  
  Noodles and Ramen
  
  Boxed Sides and Meals
  
  Beans
  
  Seeds
  
  Spices and Seasonings
  
  Dry Soup
  
  More Dry Goods
- Baking Goods
  
  Baking Mixes
  
  Frosting and Cake Decorations
  
  Baking Milks
  
  Baking Chocolate
  
  Flour
  
  Maple Syrup, Honey and Sweeteners
  
  Baking Powders
  
  Pie Crusts and Fillings
  
  Extracts
  
  Sugars
  
  Marshmallows
  
  Ice Cream Cones
- Snacks & Candy
  
  Chocolate and Candy
  
  Chips
  
  Popcorn and Pretzels
  
  Snack Bars
  
  Cookies and Crackers
  
  Nuts, Seeds and Dried Fruits
  
  Pudding and Snack Cups
  
  Jerky
  
  Gum and Mints
  
  More Snacks
- Pet Care
  
  Dry Dog Food
  
  Wet Dog Food
  
  Dog Treats
  
  Dry Cat Food
  
  Wet Cat Food
  
  Cat Treats
  
  Dog Toys and Supplies
  
  Cat Toys and Supplies
  
  Bird Care
- Alcohol
  
  Beer
  
  Wine
  
  Spirits
  
  Mixers and Non-Alcoholic Drinks
  
  Cider
  
  Ready to Drink
- Baby & Child Care
  
  Diapers, Wipes and Creams
  
  Baby Food and Drinks
  
  Baby Health Care
- Kitchen & Dining
  
  Foil and Plastic Wrap
  
  Napkins
  
  Cookware and Bakeware
  
  Dining Utensils
  
  Kitchen Gadgets and Appliances
  
  Food Storage
  
  Disposable Utensils, Plates and Cups
Catering
Sandwich Order Form
Vintage Wine & Spirits
About Us
Contact
Shop & Give
Personal Shopping Form
Holiday Meals
Meat Dept Turkey Orders
Apply for a Job

Search

Collection: Nut Butters

Sort by:

40 products

Sort by:

Sort

Sort

40 products

Sort by:

Remove all

40 products

Barney Butter Bare Smooth Almond Butter 10 oz

Barney Butter Bare Smooth Almond Butter 10 oz

Regular price $11.79

Regular price ~~$11.79~~ Sale price $11.79
Unit price per
Barney Crunchy Almond Butter 10 oz

Barney Crunchy Almond Butter 10 oz

Regular price $10.99

Regular price ~~$10.99~~ Sale price $10.99
Unit price per
Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

Regular price $9.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Santa Cruz Organic No Stir Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter Spread, 16 Ounces

Santa Cruz Organic No Stir Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter Spread, 16 Ounces

Regular price $9.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Santa Cruz Organic No Stir Crunchy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter Spread, 16 Ounces

Santa Cruz Organic No Stir Crunchy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter Spread, 16 Ounces

Regular price $9.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Santa Cruz Organic Crunchy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

Santa Cruz Organic Crunchy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, 16 Ounces

Regular price $9.99

Regular price ~~$9.99~~ Sale price $9.99
Unit price per
Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, 26 Ounces

Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter, 26 Ounces

Regular price $15.99

Regular price ~~$15.99~~ Sale price $15.99
Unit price per
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 16-Ounce Jar

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter, 16-Ounce Jar

Regular price $4.49

Regular price ~~$4.49~~ Sale price $4.49
Unit price per
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter 28 oz

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter 28 oz

Regular price $7.49

Regular price ~~$7.49~~ Sale price $7.49
Unit price per
Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 28-Ounce Jar

Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter, 28-Ounce Jar

Regular price $7.49

Regular price ~~$7.49~~ Sale price $7.49
Unit price per
Laura Scudders Old Fashioned Peanut Butter 16 oz - Nutty Peanut Butter

Laura Scudders Old Fashioned Peanut Butter 16 oz - Nutty Peanut Butter

Regular price $5.49

Regular price ~~$5.49~~ Sale price $5.49
Unit price per
Laura Scudders Old Fashioned Peanut Butter 16 oz - Smooth Peanut Butter

Laura Scudders Old Fashioned Peanut Butter 16 oz - Smooth Peanut Butter

Regular price $5.49

Regular price ~~$5.49~~ Sale price $5.49
Unit price per
Once Again Organic Lightly Sweetened Creamy Peanut Butter 16 oz

Once Again Organic Lightly Sweetened Creamy Peanut Butter 16 oz

Regular price $11.69

Regular price ~~$11.69~~ Sale price $11.69
Unit price per
Once Again Organic Creamy Unsweetened Tahini 16 oz

Once Again Organic Creamy Unsweetened Tahini 16 oz

Regular price $14.49

Regular price ~~$14.49~~ Sale price $14.49
Unit price per
Joyva Tahini 15 oz

Joyva Tahini 15 oz

Regular price $12.49

Regular price ~~$12.49~~ Sale price $12.49
Unit price per
Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter 16.3 oz

Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter 16.3 oz

Regular price $4.39

Regular price ~~$4.39~~ Sale price $4.39
Unit price per

1
2
3

Shop
More Departments
Catering
Sandwich Order Form
Vintage Wine & Spirits
About Us
Contact
Shop & Give
Personal Shopping Form
Holiday Meals
Meat Dept Turkey Orders
Apply for a Job

Subscribe to our emails

Email

Facebook
Instagram
Twitter

Payment methods

© 2025, Mill Valley Market Powered by Grocerist

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.